Immigration: U.S. warns schools against bias

'Troubling' reports of school districts making it tough to enroll immigrant children
AP Wire
May 10, 2014

Despite a 32-year-old court ruling, school districts continue to raise barriers to enrollment for children brought into the U.S. illegally, the Obama administration said Thursday, characterizing reports of hindrances as troubling.

The Justice Department and Education Department issued new guidance reminding schools and districts they have a legal obligation to enroll every student regardless of immigration status. The guidance says schools should be flexible in deciding which documents they will accept to prove a student's age or residency.

The guidance also reminds them not to ask about a student's immigration status or require documents such as a driver's license, if that would prevent a student from enrolling because of a parent's immigration status.

The Education Department said it had received 17 complaints involving 14 schools or districts for possible violations since 2011. The only cases still open are in Louisiana, New Mexico and South Carolina.

Education Secretary Arne Duncan said that in some instances, school leaders have inappropriately required information such as a child's visa status or date of entry into the United States.

Justice Department officials said they also have taken action, sometimes collaboratively with the Education Department and sometimes working separately. The Justice Department has entered into settlement agreements with school districts in states such as Georgia, Florida, and Virginia. And it said that after it contacted officials in Alabama, the state education department sent guidance to districts spelling out that they may not bar or discourage students from enrollment because they lack a Social Security number or birth certificate or because their parents don't have an Alabama driver's license.

In a settlement with the district in Palm Beach County, Florida, the district agreed to provide translation help during enrollment and to permit homeless students who lack documentation to enroll.

In Henry County, Georgia, as part of a separate settlement, the district agreed to ensure that a parent's decision to withhold a child's Social Security number will not keep the child from enrolling.

J.D. Hardin, a spokesman for Henry County schools, said students never were barred from classes in the district, located about 20 minutes south of metro Atlanta. District officials believed they could start to withdraw a child under Georgia's enrollment rules if a parent didn't provide a Social Security number or fill out a waiver within 30 days after the student began classes, he said.

Since the settlement, students stay in class, Hardin said.

Matt Cardoza, a spokesman for Georgia's Education Department, said the state worked with federal officials while updating enrollment requirements in 2011. Cardoza said state education staff will follow up on any complaints they receive about enrollment problems.

Officials from the U.S. Education and Justice departments said they have found that states and districts are willing to work with the federal government on the issue.

"It's a tribute to educators around the country that they recognize how important it is for kids to be able to attend school and are willing to take the steps necessary to ensure they aren't even inadvertently chilling students' willingness or families' willingness to attend them," said Jocelyn Samuels, acting assistant attorney general for civil rights in the Justice Department.

Attorney General Eric Holder told reporters his department "will do everything it can to make sure schools meet this obligation."

Children brought into the U.S. illegally are guaranteed the right to a K-12 education under the 1982 Supreme Court decision Plyler v. Doe.

Noelle M. Ellerson, associate executive director for policy and advocacy at AASA: The School Superintendents Association, said in an email that the association appreciates the additional clarification.

Here's a list of the schools and districts and the status of the complaints:

Maricopa Community College District, Arizona: Allegations resolved, case closed.

Douglas County Public Schools, Colorado: Allegations resolved, case closed.

Basis DC Public Charter School, District of Columbia: Agreement reached, department's Office of Civil Rights monitoring.

Capital City Public Charter School, District of Columbia: Agreement reached, department's Office of Civil Rights monitoring.

Jefferson Parish Public School System, Louisiana: Still under investigation.

Kentwood Public Schools, Michigan: Allegations resolved, case closed.

Kansas City USD 500, Kansas (four complaints): Agreement reached in three cases, department's Office of Civil Rights monitoring. Complaint withdrawn in fourth case.

Oak Grove R-VI School District, Missouri: Allegations resolved, case closed.

Albuquerque Public Schools, New Mexico: Still under investigation.

Durham County School District, North Carolina: Allegations resolved, case closed.

Lancaster Fairfield Community School, Ohio: Case closed, technical assistance provided.

Bucyrus City School District, Ohio: Referred to Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service, allegations resolved.

Beaufort County School District, South Carolina: Still under investigation.

Waynesboro County School Division, Virginia: Agreement reached, department's Office of Civil Rights monitoring.

Complaint is from a charter high school the college operates.

Source: Education Department's Office of Civil Rights



After traveling all over the world and my two sybalings as well living for years on five continents there is no where you can stay without a passport and or a visa for more than 90 days. Why a baby dropped here is an American citizen or a person extending their stay illegally here has any expectation of rights is beyond comprehension. Try this anywhere around the world and you will find yourself deported. Deliver them home, there is a legal way to immigrate here, do the paper work.


great way to drag down current students! Great think Otard. If they are not legal, kick em' out NOW

Post a Comment

Log in to your account to post comments here and on other stories, galleries and polls. Share your thoughts and reply to comments posted by others. Don't have an account on Create a new account today to get started.