Them's fighting words!: The politics of place names

Is it the Persian Gulf or the Arabian Gulf? Mount McKinley or Denali? Mumbai or Bombay?
AP Wire
Aug 9, 2014


Some geographic names don't just tell us where we live or where we're going. They're also a political statement, or in the eyes of some, a politically incorrect one. They may not spark a war of the worlds, but they can cause a war of words.

China struck back last week after Japan slapped monikers on 158 previously unnamed islands off its shores. Five of them are part of a cluster that both nations claim and is itself the subject of a name dispute: Is it the Senkaku or the Diaoyu islands?

"No unilateral action undertaken by Japan can change the fact that Diaoyu and its surrounding islands belong to China," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said, using his country's name for the remote tropical islands in the East China Sea.

One of the most cited examples is a 1970s feud over Cyprus that played out in a United Nations forum. It started after Turkey occupied the northern part of the Mediterranean island, and replaced Greek names for villages with Turkish ones.

In a letter to the U.N. conference on geographic names, Cyprus accused Turkey of committing "all kinds of unprecedented atrocities" against the Greek population, according to retired Israeli cartographer Naftali Kadmon, who reviewed the official documents.

"They demonstrate that geographical names can constitute explosive items or, in popular terms, hot potatoes," he wrote in a 2004 article for The Cartographic Journal in Britain.

The Turkish Federated State of Cyprus, which Kadmon noted was not recognized by the U.N., responded in kind, saying, "The willful and unjustified change of names has been a political pastime of the Greek Cypriot leaders for a long number of years."

The study of geographic names is known as toponymy, and those who specialize in it say it's more than an academic pursuit.

"In a sense, naming expresses ownership, because it implies both comprehension and the legitimacy of the namer's historical and cultural legacy," professor Dan Montello wrote in a 2010 posting on the University of California, Santa Barbara, geology department's website. "Hence, colonizers and claimants to territory usually change toponyms, and the original owners usually change them back if and when they get a chance."

Saigon became Ho Chi Minh City in 1976 after the North defeated the South and its American allies in the Vietnam War.

Since 1984, it's been Burkina Faso, not Upper Volta, or Haute-Volta, as its former French rulers dubbed the West African state.

In India, part of Britain's former empire, Bombay became Mumbai in 1995, and the southern city of Madras was renamed Chennai the following year.

Politicians sometimes make these changes to stir national or ethnic pride, and some in Mumbai still feel uncomfortable with the name change, which was carried out by a nativist party that rose to power after stoking deadly anti-Muslim riots in the city, said Naresh Fernandes, the author of "City Adrift: A Short Biography of Bombay."

"Given the bloody circumstances in which the name was changed, the word Mumbai now smells to me of gloating triumphalism, and I always call the city Bombay," said Fernandes, who covered the name change as a reporter for The Associated Press in 1995.

East Asian waters are dotted with islands claimed by more than one country, putting even the names of the seas in dispute.

South Korea gained a victory this year when the U.S. state of Virginia, pressured by Korean Americans, agreed that new school textbooks should note that the Sea of Japan is also known as the East Sea, the name it prefers for the waters between the two countries.

The Philippines, locked in disputes with China over several islands and reefs, proclaimed in 2012 that part of the South China Sea would henceforth be called the West Philippine Sea.

For Japan, it was the act of naming the 158 islands last week that mattered, not the actual names. Now most of the 500 islands used to define the extent of Japan's territorial waters have been named.

"It's a rather unique mega-naming gambit to lay claim to uninhabited islands, reflecting Tokyo's concern that Beijing might name and claim for itself," said Jeff Kingston, a professor of contemporary Japan at Temple University's campus in Tokyo.

Most of the islands are tiny outcroppings whose one requirement is that their highest point remains above water at high tide. About half of them had names used by fishermen and others, and the government adopted those as the official ones. The others, mainly in more remote waters, were given generic directional names such as Southeast Small Island, indicating their location relative to other geographic features.

The exercise has brought to light some unusual names. An island off the Pacific coast in western Japan is called Soviet Island, though it is nowhere near Russia. The island, which sits about 500 meters (yards) offshore, is a popular fishing ground. Toshio Horitani, an official in Susami, the nearest town, described it as the size of a living room, and said people can stand on it when the water is calm.

There's no record of how it got its name.

"I believe people meant it's so far away, like (the) Soviet (Union), because it's the furthest from the shore," said Horitani, who has been fielding calls from journalists asking about the name's origins.

Name changes can cause diplomatic angst. The then-military government changed Burma to Myanmar in 1989, but the U.S. still refers to it in official documents as Burma, a name preferred by some in the Southeast Asian country's opposition. On a visit in late 2012, President Barack Obama used "Myanmar" when talking to the president, but "Burma" in a meeting with opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi.

"We've said we recognize that different people call this country by different names," U.S. Deputy National Security Adviser Ben Rhodes told reporters afterward. "Our view is that is something we can continue to discuss."

As elsewhere in the world, the debate goes on.



Another good example of politicized place names is the Republic of Macedonia. It's one of the republics created after the breakup of Yugoslavia. Unfortunately, Greece doesn't want it to have that name; there is a region in Greece called Macedonia already (and many Greek Macedonians live there). Furthermore, Greece links its own history to that of the Macedonian Empire of Alexander the Great, and they don't appreciate the connotation of someone else using the name. Meanwhile, Macedonia points out they are Macedonians, too, and speak Macedonian. Greece, the bankrupt sick child of the EU, is holding up Macedonia's efforts to gain admission to the European Union until the name dispute is settled.

They've been negotiating since 1995. Greece wants the country to use "Northern Macedonia." The temporary solution used by countries that don't want to take a side is FYROM (Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia). Today, they're to the point that they can agree to add "Upper" to the name. Macedonia wants "Upper Republic of Macedonia," while Greece insists upon "Republic of Upper Macedonia." Greece also says that the name has to be used on everything. It's rather farcical.

Former Grandhavenite

In related news, the Ottawa County Commission has threatened to recall its ambassador to Canada in protest over the Canadian federal government's appropriation of the Ottawa name for their national capitol.

One of the more amusing country naming mistakes recently was during the 2012 Summer Olympics, when the North Korean women's soccer team was introduced with a huge image of the South Korean flag on the jumbotron. I guess the person running the display had to look up the image of the flag in a guide of some sort, and because "Democratic People's Republic of Korea" (aka North Korea) was listed alphabetically before "Republic of Korea" (aka South Korea) he probably figured that was the one he wanted. Of course the North Koreans took things in stride with the laid back, happy go lucky, and friendly attitude for which the Kim family is known far and wide.


Post a Comment

Log in to your account to post comments here and on other stories, galleries and polls. Share your thoughts and reply to comments posted by others. Don't have an account on Create a new account today to get started.