Police chiefs, sheriffs oppose land line measure

Michigan police chiefs and sheriffs on Monday came out against legislation that would make it easier for phone companies to stop offering traditional land line service, saying it would put seniors and rural residents at risk during emergencies.
AP Wire
Dec 10, 2013

The bill won overwhelmingly approval in the Senate last week and could see quick passage from the House this week before lawmakers adjourn for the year.

It's backed by AT&T and other phone providers as a way to streamline regulations and free up money for Internet-based land lines and wireless technology instead of having to spend on traditional wire lines that customers are dropping. It's opposed by the AARP and groups that represent Michigan police chiefs and county sheriffs. State Attorney General Bill Schuette also still has concerns despite the Senate adding in more consumer protections, a spokeswoman said Monday.

Robert Stevenson, executive director of the Michigan Association of Chiefs of Police, told reporters that when he was Livonia's chief during the 2003 power blackout, cell towers were jammed and Voice over Internet Protocol, or VOIP, lines had no power.

"We had no communication other than the people that had land lines," he said at a news conference. "The only reliable communication that's in this state right now are land lines."

Starting in 2017, the legislation would remove state regulators from the front end of a process by which phone providers can ask to end wire line service. They would still need clearance from federal regulators.

The bill would let customers losing traditional service ask the Michigan Public Service Commission to investigate whether "comparable voice service with reliable access to 911" is still available. If the commission decided that such service was not available, it would force the current company to provide service until another willing provider was available.

"That's not a reasonable burden to put on anybody to maintain what could be a life-and-death service," said Eric Schneidewind, a former PSC chairman who sits on the AARP's board of directors.

Matt Resch, a spokesman for AT&T of Michigan, said VoIP and mobile phones work with 911, noting that 83 percent of 911 calls placed on AT&T's network last year were made on a cellphone.

"People have more access to 911 today than they ever have," he said.

Addressing concerns about VoIP's compatibility with medical alert systems, Resch said AT&T technicians make sure the devices work with the phone system before leaving a house and medical-alert companies are increasingly moving toward wireless technology. He said the bill passed overwhelmingly in the Senate and is sponsored by a former state police trooper.

The number of traditional land lines in Michigan dropped from 6.7 million in 2000 to 2.6 million last year, according to the Federal Communications Commission. In the same period, the number of wireless lines increased from 3.5 million to 9.3 million. Another 1.4 million land line users were served with VoIP.

The FCC is looking to state regulators for guidance on transitioning away from traditional land lines, so Michigan's input will be heard, Resch said. The PSC is neutral on the legislation.

"We're not talking about any of this happening tomorrow or next week or even next year," Resch said.

Senate Bill 636: http://1.usa.gov/18GqQoG




Welcome to the future, it will happen sooner or latter, a push from the service providers, but they better finish some of their projects like at&t, many residents here in grand haven still don't have fiber optic service and still can not get at&t universe so maybe that's good for chater, remember the day when aol provided dial-up service, no longer available, how many seniors getting pensions and barley getting by can afford cable tv and many dont even want internet because they dont know what a computer is all about, my dad still is using his big antenna on top of his house with a rotor to watch tv and refuse to for cable


Just think many people still don't have cable TV because the cable service is so expensive. If they dropped the rates to get people off the free TV stations then maybe... But I don't ever see it totally due to the fact that its a law that the TV stations provide HD and the public wants local news on cable so it cost the cable companies lots of cash to provide this service. Maybe if the cable service started its own local stations. Maybe another reason why the police departments do want this to occur is the cut in 911 service budgets due to the mandated tax on your phone bill. Most state 911 services are county ran and should be covered by over our state and county taxes not some new tax and phone service tax.


I know of a large company, as of last year, upgraded to the lastest fiber optic service and removed the old wire system, the fiber optic service center takes up a size of a double garage, with a climate control, every office is equipped with lightning speed internet so each employee can watch telecast from head quarters instead of traveling, so i think this idea can be possible


Clearly some of you don't know how 911 works. As it says in the article, people in rural areas (who may not have cell coverage) can't call for help. Not to mention, cell phones don't always work, nor do they show your exact location. A landline (given it isn't a ViOP) shows exactly where you are calling from. That alone is enough reason to have a landline. You dial 911, become unconscious right after, good luck having them find you. Your cell phone could show you in a different location than your house.

The 911 tax is minimal, compared to how it could save your life or someone else's.

Post a Comment

Log in to your account to post comments here and on other stories, galleries and polls. Share your thoughts and reply to comments posted by others. Don't have an account on GrandHavenTribune.com? Create a new account today to get started.