GH Twp. sued in federal court

Grand Haven Township and its elected supervisor are the targets of a lawsuit filed recently in federal court.
Becky Vargo
Sep 4, 2012

The township's ordinance officer and building inspector, Barton Lucas, has also been named a defendant in the suit.

This lawsuit comes as motions are going through Ottawa County District Court on what Todd Glockzin claims are violations of an agreement made with the township in 2010 regarding his heating and cooling business.

Both Township Manager Bill Cargo and Township Supervisor Karl French said the civil actions are “frivolous.” Cargo also said they are “without merit.”

Glockzin, French’s former business partner, claims in the federal lawsuit that the defending parties conspired against him when he was ticketed more than 50 times for not requesting permits for work. Most of the work involved in the case was done when Glockzin was still French's partner in the heating and cooling business.

French was not ticketed. French said that's because Glockzin had taken over all the assets and liabilities of the business — including all of the customers — when their partnership was dissolved.

The lawsuit claims that the conspiracy evolved when Glockzin refused “to unfairly remunerate” French in connection with the dissolution of their partnership, Glockzin French Heating and Cooling. It notes that French was elected township supervisor while they were working to dissolve the company, which had been in business from Aug. 1, 2001, to Dec. 31, 2005.

To see the lawsuit documents, click the Related File PDF below this story.

The suit also notes that the separation was not friendly.

French, who said he was speaking for himself and not for the township, said the split was not as tumultuous as claimed in the lawsuit.

“I don’t believe it was a hostile break-up between us,” French said. “I made him an offer, he accepted and we went our different ways.”

Glockzin and French continue to run separate heating and cooling businesses in the Grand Haven area.

The lawsuit claims that French – before and after taking office as township supervisor – contacted other local government officials in an effort to get them to issue citations against Glockzin in connection with work done in their municipalities.

In the meantime, French was demanding more money from Glockzin, the lawsuit notes.

Glockzin also claims in the suit that French demanded he pay him $2,000 for the business dissolution. Glockzin says French then threatened him in a letter that, if he didn't make the payment, "It will end up costing you far more."

Glockzin claims he refused to make the payment and in February 2009, “French utilized confidential and proprietary information he had from being a shareholder and partner in Glockzin French Heating and Cooling and directed (Grand Haven Township building inspector Barton) Lucas to issue a citation to Glockzin for failing to obtain a final inspection following the installation of a furnace by Glockzin French Heath and Cooling."

That spring, Glockzin started receiving tickets from Lucas, the lawsuit noted.

After extended negotiations, Glockzin and the township eventually reached a settlement.

French said that he turned over the names of the company’s customers to the township at Glockzin’s request. The township then went through the list and issued the citations.

The township eventually filed a lawsuit against Glockzin, which was dismissed on
March 11, 2010, said Ottawa County District Judge Richard Kloote.

“It was a consent to dismiss, based on a settlement agreement between the parties,” Kloote said.

On July 13, Glockzin’s attorney, Ross Reuterdahl, filed a motion to show cause, based on a claim that the township violated the agreement “when they sent out a letter to a customer,” Kloote said.

“I refused to set a hearing on their request,” Kloote said.

The show cause hearing would have required that the township explain why they should not be held in contempt for allegedly violating the agreement.

The judge said the plaintiffs could bring back the issue at a later date.

The current motion set for a hearing on Wednesday is a request by Glockzin to have the Grand Haven law firm Scholten Fant removed as the township attorneys for the case.

Township attorney Brad Springer of Scholten Fant said the agreement says the township can’t contact the company's customers, but it also says “that nothing in the settlement agreement prohibits the township from disclosing any information about violations of the mechanical code that it would have a legal obligation to disclose.”

“We have a situation where the township is required by law to administer and enforce the requirements of the mechanical code, which ultimately has as its core purpose the safety of the people that live in the geographical limits of the township,” Springer said.

French said Glockzin has filed previous lawsuits, which have been dismissed. French said he had not filed any in return.

“If it had been a hostile breakup, there would probably have been lawsuits filed by me as well,” French said.

 

Comments

Fly on the Wall

It wasn't just Glockzin. I had a HVAC firm over to look at a furnace problem. The tech hit me with some high pressure sales tactics and disconnected my furnace, claiming it was a hazard. I called another company for a second opinion. Company #2 made some quick fixes, rebooted the unit and said I should be good for a month, and emailed a quote for a new unit. Less than two weeks later, I received a notice for not having a permit pulled for a furnace installation. I had at this time given a verbal notice to proceed to contractor #2, but the work hadn't been done. A call to my chosen contractor revealed that a few local contractors are known to make service calls, disable units and send notice to the building inspector that a permit request will be forthcoming. Dirty tricks by slimeball contractors. I'll be watching this one.

snlfan

So let me get this straight.... Glockzin and French owned a HVAC business together, they decide to split up... Around the same time French gets elected to Township Supervisor... The business split up is contested between the two and suddenly Glockzin is getting hammered with problems from the Township...??? Hmmm seems like someone in power holding a grudge or other ill will? Seems harry to me, what is going on with this French guy?

kld44

Just goes to show, that the all-mighty dollar rules all, and it doesn't matter who gets hurt in the process. Although, I personally have known Mr. Glockzin to be quite sneaky.

dotherightthing

Did someone say write-in candidate? The township folks may want to find someone who does not use their elected position to gain an unfair competitive advantage in the cut-throat heating and cooling business. BTW, why is there a French truck always parked across the street from the Glockzin shop?

PeopleAreAmazing

They're stopping by to get advice?

43°North

haha, now that was funny there!

newspaperlawyer

How about when French got the bid on work at the Twp hall... Karl French has always been a sneaky little S..t like Nedermeyer... Maybe some question needs to be asked about the bids on the new fire truck also... some sneaky stuff going on from what I hear from a board member. It's time for a house cleaning from the board down to Cargo..

mamat

Obviously before the business went kaput, I think in winter 2005, our furnace went out in the winter (we aren't in Grand Haven Twp). We contacted Glockzin/French and French came out. He was able to fix our furnace quickly and cheaply but told us we'd need a new furnace and central air before summer/next heating season (sooner rather than later). It was French who came out. About three months later, French showed up at our door, the excuse was that our check had been misplaced and never cashed (it had been cashed shortly after the repair) and he wanted another check. When I told him it had been cashed, he changed the subject and brought up our heater/central air. I told him we weren't interested at that time. Fall 2005, I called a company out of Holland who we had check the furnace for the upcoming winter. I asked if there was anything wrong with the furnace and if we'd need to purchase a new one. He told us it was fine and would last several more years. He couldn't understand why we were told it wouldn't. The ironic thing about the whole deal was we'd been through a home inspection in 2004 and told it would be quite a few years before we needed a new furnace. Of course, we never called them (Glockzin/French) back and upgraded our furnace in 2007.

ghresident

Ive used Glockzin heating for a couple service calls now, it was Todd who made one sevice call and one of his workers on the other. Neither of them recommended any un nessassary services or said I should upgrade anything, both were very proffessional and on time with our appointments. You can get good and bad with any company. Just because todd's in the spotlight, I guess he's getting a little heat.

newspaperlawyer

I would think this is a case for the attorney generals office or the State Polices Major Crime Unit to investigate this. The use of an elected officials position for personal gains.

Post a Comment

Log in to your account to post comments here and on other stories, galleries and polls. Share your thoughts and reply to comments posted by others. Don't have an account on GrandHavenTribune.com? Create a new account today to get started.