IDEMA: On religion, was Karl Marx right?

Sep 12, 2012


His economics leave a lot to be desired, especially by underestimating his own Jewish doctrine of sin and the human selfishness and will to power that the story of Adam and Eve illuminates. Worldly goods will never be distributed based on "each according to his or her ability and need."

On religion, however, Marx had some profound ideas which illuminate the use of religion in our political campaigns.

Here is his most famous statement on religion from his essay "Contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right":

"Religious suffering is at the same time an expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions."

He concludes, "Religion is the opium of the people."

One does not have to be a religious believer to appreciate the truth of his observation.

Consider the consolation of religion for black slaves in the 1800s in America, or the hope and faith directed at God by a parent whose child has cancer. In times of stress and conflict, we all need something to soothe us. Some people smoke a joint, have a cocktail, or chain smoke.

Others flock to the pews, as we did after 9-11. Churches were packed, for a while. Then attendance went back to normal.

The function of religion as a means to discover hope and share in God's love within a caring community is undeniable.

Marx also wrote about a darker side of religion; how it is used by the upper class to keep others within their place in the social structure. To dampen change and even revolution, in other words.

For Marx, what made society tick was class structure and the distribution of wealth. Those with the most money use religion as part of power politics to maintain their wealth and place in the structure of society.

Karl Rove saw, with brilliant insight, that evangelistic Christianity, especially in the South, could be wedded to "country club Republicans" — and thus create an unbeatable coalition when Bush and Gore, then Kerry, squared off. Churches and corporations married, but it was an uneasy marriage, and the stresses are now evident.

For example, the GOP platform is against abortion, with no stated exceptions. This is a huge issue in many churches, but hardly in corporate boardrooms. Business people on TV decry the "crazies" in the GOP, and many evangelical Christians distrust the corporate world, and sometimes suspect they are being used to attain power, after which their agenda will then be neglected. Overturning Roe v. Wade was hardly a priority for either Ronald Reagan or George W. Bush.

To sum up a very complex social dynamic for a short article, Marx saw religion as the expression of real suffering, especially economic. In our present economy, those with stock portfolios are much better off than four years ago, but the unemployed and underemployed are not.

Marx also saw, correctly, that politicians will use religion as a means to maintain or attain economic and political power. Both parties do this from different perspectives; e.g., the social gospel vs. biblical literalism. The GOP has been incredibly effective in convincing people to vote against their own economic self-interest, using religion as a way of motivating voters.

Religion can never be removed from our politics. However, using Marx as a lens, we can see how people today in this upcoming election are using religion, both sincerely and insincerely, to maintain their power and wealth, or as the lubricant to attain them.

As Marx taught us, to understand society, follow the money. To understand religion, see how both the rich and poor use it for their own economic agendas.

— By the Rev. Henry Idema, Tribune religion columnist



Very thought provoking article. I only have one question for you, Reverend. Having stated "His economics leave a lot to be desired ...'Worldly goods will never be distributed based on 'each according to his or her ability and need.'" do you agree that President Obama's adherence to this undesirable economic policy is misguided?

Tri-cities realist

Great question Vlad. I have another. Rev Idema stated "The GOP has been incredibly effective in convincing people to vote against their own economic self-interest, using religion as a way of motivating voters." How does keeping more of their hard earned money through lower taxes, somehow violate their own economic self-interest? I think it is correct to say that the Democrats do this, rather than the GOP.


An amazingly well crafted attack on the conservatives. Undoubtedly spent as much time on this opinion as one of his sermons. To somehow turn the moral fiber and God believing ideals of the men who built this country into political demagoguery is an assault on me, my father, and my grandfather as well as this community. This is a perfect example of the divisiveness the current administration is trying to cultivate amongst Americans in its current campaign. It would be enlightening to be a fly on the wall at an Obama roundtable meeting, replete with all his slick willy campaign advisors mocking the the average American voter, characterizing religion. I think one would find that the Obama campaign believes that they are the religion that the "people need". This great country was certainly not built on sarcastic pen bleeding and there are still quite a few Americans around that know that Marxist ideals and the like were worthy enemies that helped forge America into what it is still supposed to be.


"A Republic, if you can keep it" At the close of the Constitutional Convention this was the reply from Benjamin Franklin when a lady asked if we have a republic or monarchy. Those on the left would be well served if they would read what these amazing men of that time toiled over and crafted into the most incredible document of mankind.


Hey, i want to know details about the "Karl Marx" are you say me ? i eagerly waiting for your information. kindly hurry up. teenage mutant ninja turtle
good bye.


Post a Comment

Log in to your account to post comments here and on other stories, galleries and polls. Share your thoughts and reply to comments posted by others. Don't have an account on Create a new account today to get started.