OTHER VIEWS: Wrong time to sign gun bill

No rationale exists for the tragic loss of life last week on the East and West coasts. The heartache caused by these senseless shootings will leave permanent emotional scars on all close to the victims.
Dec 18, 2012


In the wake of this violence, Gov. Rick Snyder should veto a bill that would expand where individuals can carry concealed weapons.

On Friday morning, a gunman killed 26 people — 20 of whom were young children — at an elementary school in Newtown, Conn. The horror everyone involved must have felt is beyond words. And the loss of such young, innocent life is heartbreaking.

Earlier in the week, another gunman killed two people who were out shopping at Clackamas Town Center near Portland, Ore.

In the flurry of bills that emanated from the Michigan Legislature last week, lawmakers sent a bill, Senate Bill 59, to the governor. SB 59 would allow more highly trained gun owners to carry their weapons into previously barred venues, including schools, day care centers, churches and stadiums.

The bill also contains a provision for private businesses to opt out if they don't wish guns on their premises. Schools could create "no-gun zones," but they couldn't opt out entirely. That's unacceptable.

Snyder didn't request this gun bill, in addition to several other bills that center on social issues, and he would be justified in sending it back to the Legislature. On Friday, he told The Detroit News those bills would receive extra scrutiny.

Looking ahead, the gun bill contains some good provisions that could form the basis of new legislation.Current law permits gun owners to carry their weapon without a permit if it is openly exposed. That's led to people showing up in other public places with visible guns on their hips, or even in their hands. This law restricts that.

A separate gun-related bill also passed out of the Legislature, and it requires the Michigan State Police, instead of local law enforcement, to keep gun purchase records. It also eases some license requirements to purchase a handgun. That bill seems less volatile.

But in light of last week's tragedies, this is not the time for more guns on school grounds.

The vast majority of those who hold concealed carry permits respect firearms and most do not commit such violent crimes. In fact, they may be able to help by stopping gunmen before police get on the scene.

While we remain strong Second Amendment advocates and generally oppose knee-jerk responses, surely prudence is called for at this hour.

These bills deserve the governor's scrutiny and can easily wait until the next legislative session.


What do you think? Should the governor sign the legislation? Vote now in our online poll!



Now we have the right to work for LESS, How Stupid!!!! I bet Snyder didn't cut the wages of the Politian's in Lansing. Thank You, Thank You Very little


Since Snyder refuses to allow the schools to be safe for our children, I'm pulling my child OUT! Home schooling is the only safe place for her now. Refusing to let the well trained responsible gun owners to be armed on school property only ENCOURAGES more psychopaths to kill more innocents!


The title of this "opinion" is intreging. "Wrong Time to Sign Gun Bill." Let's think this through: Another act of violence against the innocent in a place that the government has dilibertly disarmed its citizens and it is the "wrong time?" Another where you might as well put a sign out front to evil men that says, "No one here can protect themselves" and it is the "wrong time?" When will be the "right time" for citizens to protect themsevles? The government has the responsibility to protect us and when it can't we are to protect ourselves. How many more killings before you all realize we are in a war zone!!! You can pass "feel good" laws to make your political cache but I prefer to protect myself by getting my head out of the sand and realizing their are evil men out there that want to hurt is. Or, is all this logic simply the "wrong time?"

Wayne Justinen

It is not, and never has been, the government's responsibility to protect us.

The reason self-defense isn't mentioned in the second ammendment is it was a given that people have the right, and the responsibility, to defend themselves.

Wayne Justinen


Solution of problem one:

A. When attacked, call someone with a gun to stop the attack, or

B. When attacked, use personally carried gun to stop the attack.

The answer is B.

Governor Rick Snyder failed the test.


Post a Comment

Log in to your account to post comments here and on other stories, galleries and polls. Share your thoughts and reply to comments posted by others. Don't have an account on GrandHavenTribune.com? Create a new account today to get started.