The Kent County Circuit Court jury deliberated about four hours before convicting Root of second-degree murder, which is punishable by up to life in prison. Root, 55, showed little emotion when the verdict was announced.
Three years ago, a jury also deliberated about four hours before convicting Root of first-degree murder. She was sentenced in December 2015 to life in prison.
But that first conviction was overturned by the Michigan Court of Appeals after justices said some of the evidence presented at the 2015 trial should have been off limits. Portions of a police interview occurred before Root was informed of her Miranda rights, “thus depriving her of her Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination,’’ justices wrote in a 19-page decision.
The appeals court decision in September 2017 led to a new jury trial, which got underway Monday in front of Kent County Circuit Judge Joseph Rossi.
Both sides presented opening statements to jurors Monday. The prosecution presented evidence starting Tuesday, including portions of police interviews with Root from more than three years ago.
Closing statements were given Friday morning before the case was turned over to the jury.
Ottawa County Assistant Prosecutor Lee Fisher said the evidence supports a guilty verdict of first-degree murder. Fisher, who handled the case because Kelly's body was found in Ottawa County, said he is disappointed in the lesser verdict. First-degree murder is punishable by mandatory life in prison.
"We did everything we could to try to secure a first-degree murder conviction — I think the facts were there for that,'' Fisher said outside the ninth floor courtroom. "But I do not fault the jury for reaching the decision that they did.''
Defense attorney David Dodge asked jurors to consider a lesser offense of manslaughter, which is punishable by up to 15 years in prison.
The judge ordered Root to be held without bond in the Kent County Jail ahead of her October sentencing.
The high-profile case went unsolved for several years until investigators in 2015 linked Root to the crime through DNA evidence.